Reflecting on past Empire no way to honour modern heroes
WE SHOULD all celebrate those entrepreneurs, philanthropists, charity workers, and carers who have received royal honours.
In Stoke-on-Trent, it is quite right that the business brilliance of Denise Coates CBE, the community activism of Hifsa Iqbal CBE, and the medical care of Ruth Chambers OBE have been recognised at the highest level.
But should the title of Commander or Order of the British Empire contain the word 'Empire', when the British Empire is now long gone?
That was the issue raised last week by three Lord Lieutenants. The Rt Hon George Reid, Lord Lieutenant of Clackmannshire, said there was a general "unease" about the use of the word 'empire' while the Lord Lieutenant of Cheshire, David Briggs, described it as 'inappropriate in 2012.'
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk
View detailsOur heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013
Meanwhile Sir James Cropper KCVO, Lord Lieutenant of Cumbria, called for a 'title more meaningful for the present times'.
What sparked the Lord Lieutenants' intervention was Prime Minister David Cameron's proposals to reinstate the British Empire Medal as a reward for those who make an outstanding contribution to civic life through community work and volunteering.
The original BEM was established in 1917 to recognise individuals not of sufficient 'rank' to be awarded an MBE, OBE or CBE.
This distinction was reinforced by the fact that, unlike the higher rank honours, the BEM was not personally awarded at Buckingham Palace, but by the Lord Lieutenants themselves.
It was last used in 1992 before John Major, in a drive to create a 'classless society' concluded that the distinction entrenched class divisions and suspended the honour, promising to recommend more MBEs instead.
Our current Prime Minister, with his Downton Abbey approach to British society, wants to bring it back. And, inevitably, the proposal has revived our national obsessions of class and identity.
On one point, at least, the Prime Minister is right. The number of people currently being honoured for local community work is far too low. In Bentilee, residents are rightly proud of their own 'Citizen of the Year' award (currently held by top local fundraiser Pat Roberts), but some broader national recognition would not go amiss.
Then there is the issue of 'Empire.' And on this, I tend to side with the Lord Lieutenants.
Empire is fundamental to the history and identity of modern Britain. At its peak, the British Empire involved ruling over a third of the world's population – and the story of contemporary India, America, Australia and swathes of Africa are bound up with this imperial history.
And, of course, the impact of Empire floated back onto these shores. From chicken tikka massala to bungalows to Pale Ale to Imperial Leather to Wembley Stadium to Liverpool Docks, the legacy of Empire remains all around us. As do those communities brought to this country by colonialism, from the West Indians to the Pakistanis to the Gurkhas.
In Stoke-on-Trent, this history is particularly powerful. Wherever you travel around the world – from the University Clocktower, in Mumbai, to the plantation houses of Jamaica to the Capitol Building in Washington – the great Potteries' brands can be found.
The riches of Stoke-on-Trent were built on exporting Spode, Minton, Wedgwood, Royal Doulton, and Johnsons to the edges of Empire. We should also not forget that the greatest bard of Empire, Rudyard Kipling, was a product of North Staffordshire thanks to his father Lockwood Kipling's post at the Burslem School of Art.
In turn, the Empire came back to Stoke in the post-war years with the arrival of a large Pakistani community to work on the pot-banks.
However, that is now history. Hong Kong was handed back in 1997 and, aside from a few overseas territories, we are no longer an Empire. So that should surely be reflected in our honours system. We should keep the titles of OBE, MBE, and CBE, as they are well recognised and appreciated, but we should change 'Empire' for 'Excellence' to have Commanders, Officers and Members of the British Order of Excellence.
It might not be so historically redolent, but it would be more honest.
There is no reason why the loss of empire should diminish the status of the honour. The most prestigious honour – the Order of Merit – makes no mention of empire at all. And plenty of countries have post-imperial civilian honours that carry a tremendous amount of significance, such as the 'Order of Canada' or the Legion d'honneur in France.
It is always pleasant to bask in old glories, but it is no way to honour our modern heroes or build a country focused on the global future rather than the colonial past.






Comments
by camband
Thursday, May 17 2012, 1:39PM
“Land of Hope and Glory......
Rule Britannia -Britannia Rule the Waves ......
An Englishman's home is his castle,
And for many that's now one big hassle,
With a mortgage to pay,
And his job gone away,
And his wife thinks she's just a spare vassal.”
by BritishHope
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 3:12PM
“"We are in the EU because it suits us to be in it.
We pay full dues and receive around 50% of it back"
Who says it suits us? It doesnt seem to be.
Why not keep 100% and concentrate on UK? Besides, I guarentee that figure of 50% to be false in the current economic turmoil. As Europes powers have increased so have our import %. We now import a higher % than we export. Again, unsustainable.
"We pay to have a say and vote on the direction of the biggest market place on earth." - We do need this market place NOW, because we have no manufacturing in the country. A backbone we need to build strong foundations and the jobs that come with it create a good civil morality and work ethic. (Also more disposable income thus shops and business benifit).
"We are a Parliamentary democracy where we decide our voice every five years and we need not consult the general public on matters not concerning any constitutional changes to the way Britain operates." - David Cameron and Co are doing an excellent job arnt they.. oh so did Tony Blair. The money people who can secure places of such high authority are the people in charge so dont kid yourself its fair.
Yes, Greece need help. But , and a very good saying from my Grandad, 'look to yourself before turning to anyone else' - the Greeks have smashed up cities across their country, while in a financial disaster, seemingly to continue to kick the can and carry one. It was not me, you or anyone else ordinary that landed Greece in such turmoil but yet we are expected to help a bail out? Why? Through the good of our hearts? Even our own govt offers no help to British strugglers, they increase a tax and put more pressure on us.
So Europe is a good idea. But its all it is, too many conflicting cultures and ways of life, idea's and econmic systems that ultimatly cannot be controlled.
- It would also help if polititions were straight talking.”
by mole10
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 2:36PM
“We are in the EU because it suits us to be in it.
We pay full dues and receive around 50% of it back.
We pay to have a say and vote on the direction of the biggest market place on earth.
Europe is very much something we need as we are European first and foremost and the EU gives us much more than a serving Empire once did.
We are a Parliamentary democracy where we decide our voice every five years and we need not consult the general public on matters not concerning any constitutional changes to the way Britain operates.
A depression similar to the 1930's has returned because we allow fellow Europeans too much flexibility (and lies) to spend however they like and not caution them under collective fiscal rules of which is the sole answer to this current crisis.
Every effort should be made to help our fellow Europeans in Greece to come out the other side financially stable and any talk of offloading them should be suspect.
Being independent of the Euro offered no protection whatsoever and we hide behind the falsehood that £ sterling gives us a comfort zone of protection from nasty Europeans and a nasty unworkable currency.
This is wrong and only gave us QE which we pay a fortune to sustain.
Not only that, we pay a similar fortune through the back-door of the IMF while the politicians who sign the cheques rant on not giving in to Europe and the EU.
It's a lie.”
by BritishHope
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 2:18PM
“And as for Greece, if they finally make a coailition government and are successfully bailed out, how long until Spain come with their hands out as they are in serious trouble.
The EU doesnt work, as we are finding out. Its costing us a lot more than anyone else too. So wheres the fairness in it all.”
by BritishHope
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 1:41PM
“Independant of the Euro so why be involved in the EU?
Regardless of any other nation, the ultimatle problem lies with the banks and society. The loan culture of the 21st century is tottally unsustainable. As proved.
We need a complete reform in goverment policies and more delegation to your ordinary working class people - as from my experience these are the people 99% of the time are correct.
Europe isnt something we need, and in circumstances like Greece - we should have a national vote wether to help or not. Consult the country, before anyone else.
Running a country is like running a business, its customers are the people. The purpose of business is to please the customer... and are you a pleased one at this moment in time? I am not.
Maybe my history could be better with regards to 1930's - but all i know is my Grandad has said for 10 years now that one day it will go back to the 1930's and there will be real doeses of poverty the likes of which only my grandads generation can remember.”
by mole10
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 12:58PM
“Britain is independent of the Euro and offers us no protection whatsoever from any currency on earth.
The protectionism you crave is a known failure of the 1930's which also saw depression years.
If Greece doesn't get its 13bn Euro bailout, courtesy of you, then it could go bust to the tune of 300bn Euros which will crash Britain into the stone age.
I'm all for deporting criminals but proof would be nice.”
by BritishHope
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 11:28AM
“I vote for UKIP. Europe controls us, we're in a economic crisis and need to be independant to sort our OWN problems out, before offering billions in aid to others.
I do respect the logic and idea behind the EU, but ultimatly in this day an age where terrorists cant be deported without going through thr european courts of human rights takes the ****. Its a scape-goat for scum and expensive for us.”
by mole10
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 10:58AM
“Who's taking history away?
That would be the greatest achievemnet of all and truly remarkeable.
The Empire was abandoned long ago and replaced with the more superior Common Market, now the EU.
It must grate you to think that your world relies on a liberalist left wing idea but you must be very proud, surely, that no bloodshed is made in its progress.
The Empire was yesterday but today and tomorrow is the EU and ever more towards fiscal solidarity.
Surely Comrade, you wish it well?”
by BritishHope
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 10:49AM
“As I KEEP saying this is the left-wing and there nothing jobs!!!
The British Empire was hands down the greatest achievement in the history of mankind. For a country the size of Britiain and its population to conquer as much as they did is incredable and I for one can take great pride knowing my ancestors were involved.
The world over - people, ESPECIALLY IGNORANT & ARROGANT POLITICALLY CORRECT LEFT-WING, fail to recognise how much the British have influenced the whole world. No other country has achieved ANYTHING like Great Britain and considering the size of the UK... it is hands down the greatest achievement in man-kind.
So to take away any of that, is taking away your history.
The blood-shed, terrible as it may have been was just something that came with that time of the world. People wanted to build empires.
"However, that is now history" - And History is something never to be forgotten. Those good dead British who made the empire as a good as me, you or anyone else. Least we forget.
I can rant and rant and rant about his. Historys history and that Empire made us what we are today - a country of wealth and material goods.
Never forget your roots. The Empire shows to me the true British spirit that has now gone, and needs to come back. the 'we can do it' attitude'. Look at the places Britian did now have power over now, they are still very far behind the others.
"It is always pleasant to bask in old glories, but it is no way to honour our modern heroes or build a country focused on the global future rather than the colonial past." - Well do look at the past, because the present and what the future has to bring is an unfair society for the decent hard-working people.”
by mole10
Wednesday, May 16 2012, 10:10AM
“Germany 'annexing Europe' in a fiscal union?
It would be interesting to hear a view of how the Euro currency is to blame, when clearly it is not.
If fiscal union was in place from the start, then Britain would not be in recession.”