Police pull plug on Clough Hall Park fireworks display in Kidsgrove due to safety concerns
A TOWN's main bonfire and fireworks display has been cancelled after police raised safety concerns.
Kidsgrove Rotary Club, which organises the annual bonfire at Clough Hall Park, says it had not been given enough time to make improvements requested by Staffordshire Police.
-

VENUE: Clough Hall Park.
The fund-raising event, which attracts 2,000 people to the park, was due to take place on November 3, but organisers say police raised concerns over health and safety only on September 25.
This followed a 'disturbance' outside the park during last year's event, which resulted in an officer being injured.
Panasonic Store Camera•20x Optical Zoom LEICA DC Lens from 24mm...
View details
What Digital camera Gold award winning DMCTZ40
SAVE £20 off our store price ONLY with this voucher
Plus you can also claim a SD card or spare battery
Choice of colours, free parking behind store
Terms: Print this voucher and hand in at Panasonic Store Hanley to save £20 off our store price ONLY £269.90
Contact: 01782 342609
Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013
Police say they cannot support the event until certain measures are put in place. The improvements, requested following a meeting with organisers and Newcastle Borough Council, include:
increasing the number of stewards from 12 to 30;
ensuring stewards are professionally briefed on roles and responsibilities;
providing improved crowd barriers around the bonfire;
and providing additional temporary lighting all around the park.
John Howe, chairman of the club's bonfire committee, said there was no way the club could find an extra 18 stewards in time and the improvements demanded could quadruple the cost of organising the event.
The 74-year-old, of Mellor Street, Packmoor, said: "If the police had given us more time, we would certainly have tried to meet all their requirements, but three weeks was just not enough. .
"They wanted us to provide 30 stewards, and they would all have to be properly trained. We normally have about 12 stewards.
"We were surprised when the police mentioned the incident from last year, as we weren't aware of it. We've been running this event for 42 years, and we've never had any trouble."
Mr Howe said the event usually raised up to £6,000 for local and national charities every year.
He added: "We are disappointed that we've had to cancel it, but it's just one of those things. Charities are going to lose out as well, and it's not good for the council either, as they want to see their facilities in use."
Kidsgrove councillor Kyle Robinson, pictured right, said he did not believe the safety improvements were necessary.
He said: "This is just an over-zealous attitude from the police. This event has always been well run by the Rotary Club, and I don't think the support from the police is all that could be desired."
He added: "This is an important community event in Kidsgrove, and we don't have that many."
Sergeant Mark Speedman, from Newcastle borough local policing team, said the police had a duty to ensure the safety of the public and their officers.
He said: "Public safety is a top priority for Staffordshire Police and organisers of all public events have a duty to meet certain requirements.
"As a result of the event in recent years we raised our concerns regarding the overall safety of the event with Newcastle Borough Council and the organisers themselves. We expressed concern with regards to lack of lighting, alcohol issues, no safety barriers and a lack of stewards."
He said talks were ongoing with the council and another organiser with a view to staging the event.




Comments
by EysTheer
Tuesday, October 09 2012, 12:44AM
“Zoe Lovatt. You can do it for free. You could be one of the volunteers they're looking for. Now get a few of our mates and give something back to your community, and stop having a go at the Police.”
by AlexMurphy
Monday, October 08 2012, 7:11PM
“re comments of Si Richards it is not all the Police. The yobs who spoilt previous events they are just a minority of the hundreds who attend and likewise it is not all Police, many of the local! officers have supported all manner of events and on many occasions in their own time.
This hasn't helped community spirit but you only have to listen to how some neighbours behave towards each other to realise community spirit has many challenges before it.”
by valiantbez
Sunday, October 07 2012, 9:36PM
“42 years without trouble and thousands of pounds raised for worthy causes!Well done to all involved but didn't the same happen to another popular local event that raised many thousands of pounds for charity-Newcastle Carnival?H&S issues again!!!!!”
by Dymond
Sunday, October 07 2012, 2:54PM
“After 42years of successfull bonfires in the park all of a sudden it is not safe unless it is policed by a virtual army, this has to be one of the most ridiculous things I have heard, after years of being encouraged to attend community bonfires for safety reasons we are now going to encourage hundreds of people to do it yourself,crazy, a rethink please.”
by focusboy
Sunday, October 07 2012, 2:24PM
“As Kyle says, this isn't about Health & Safety, it's about Police budgets.
The event has run successfully for over 40 years. Now, all of a sudden, there are Health & Safety issues? If the event doesn't take place then it doesn't have to be policed, does it?”
by warren-lloyd
Saturday, October 06 2012, 6:22AM
“Its my right to light massive fires in a public place and set off high explosives on November the 5th, the week leading up to November the 5th, the week after November the 5th and thoughout the mouth of October.”
by yamahaman
Friday, October 05 2012, 11:13PM
“I would ask the police to name the officer who has made this decision, it is very easy to say WE, who is this WE ? it is as bad as saying THEY have said," The We and They" who always hide behind such terms, should have the backbone to stand up and be counted. Is it not safer to have a well run firework display, which has been well run in the past, than small home displays in the back garden of homes ? If there are idiots arrested at a football match would they ban the games?”
by yoblet
Friday, October 05 2012, 8:23PM
“Plebs,once again the hard working descent folk lose out because of the mindless idiots that drink and take drugs then cause trouble,and what's even worse is the police put a stop to our entertainment when they should remove the thugs off the streets instead,we pay to have our city policed not for them to cancel events so they can sit on road sides trying to fine motorists for doing less wrong than these thugs.i say again plebs.”
by truestokie
Friday, October 05 2012, 2:13PM
“If the police wanted to look like scrooges they could not have done a better job.
Wait till they want help from the public.
If I lived in Kidsgrove I would be sorely tempted to tell them to go to Hell.”
by zoe_lovatt
Friday, October 05 2012, 1:26PM
“Does noone care about thier communities anymore. If I were a Police Officer I'd do it for free. Shame on the lot of them.”