Mike Wolfe: Have faith in discussion and keep religions out of politics
I AM glad that our local trio of would-be terrorists will remain behind bars for a serious period.
I am also glad to hear of the importance that information supplied by local Muslim people played in their arrest.
I met some of the convicted offenders a few years ago.
Although little more than lads, it was a chilling experience.
They certainly didn't threaten violence or indicate that they would use it.
However, the terrifying thing about them was their driven certainty.
I wanted to discuss the state of the city and hear their views on the way young people are treated.
Instead of a response based on their experience of life in Cobridge, I was subjected to a theoretical rant about the way Muslims are oppressed worldwide.
This was interspersed with religious texts and quotes, but these were obviously learned by rote and used out of context.
I was told that militant secularists like me would have our pride punished on the day of judgment.
No surprise that they had been banned from peddling their quasi-religious twaddle in the nearby mosque.
I walked away frightened of the distance that they were putting between themselves and the real world.
Their unshakeable belief in what they felt was the revealed views of god made it impossible for them to learn about the world or discuss its ways.
I am not surprised that their blinkered vision has led them into the dark corner from which they now ponder their position.
I just hope that, once inside, they will be treated well and taught to think for themselves.
Now, at first sight, the intransigence of these terrorists would seem to have little to do with the row about prayers at council meetings.
Eric Pickles, the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, is apoplectic.
He sees the secular society's wish to separate church and state as an attack on the very fabric of Britishness.
He quickly scores maximum political points by bringing forward the implementation of new legislation which will allow councils to make prayers part of their formal agenda.
More confusingly, Tory co-chairman Baroness Warsi – a prominent Muslim – rushes to The Vatican to insist that Britain needs more Christianity not less.
And that is why they remind me of the boys, now safely behind bars, who so frightened me on the Cobridge street.
You see, although I don't believe that Pickles and Warsi want to bomb pubs, they do want our public life to be led by considerations which can only be a matter of faith.
They have long since discovered that reason alone will not win the argument about things like stem cell research or mercy killing for the terminally ill.
Instead, they subject us all to their interpretation of the views of a higher power.
The truth is that something cannot be correct just because it is part of a person's religion – otherwise the bombers are right.
Politics or public life can only proceed on the basis of discussion, reason and evidence.
To base politics on belief systems that are revealed by higher powers or otherwise not subject to negotiation is to bring about the dictatorship of the few who believe those views.
The prayers at a council meeting symbolise the preferential treatment given to religious – mostly Christian – feelings.
Whilst I have every respect for people who choose to believe in a god and associated moral codes, these are personal matters.
They can neither be proved or disproved and should remain a matter of personal choice.
I want public life in which decisions are based on thinking rather than feelings.









58 Comments
View all
by ghosts
Tuesday, February 28 2012, 11:04AM
“My 9 year old grandson told me that Allah is the best God in the world, his Asian friend told him that...He has started to ask questions about dying and Heaven...I have tried to explain that there are many religions and it is up to the individual who they worship so long as you don't try to push it on anyone else....He then asked why some people want to bomb us (his own words)....again I told him that there are some evil people in the world...Is this typical playground talk now???”
by hkrespect
Tuesday, February 28 2012, 4:03AM
“innocent
the snitches made up lies”
by hkrespect
Tuesday, February 28 2012, 3:59AM
“lirs and more lies
they planned nothing”
by stevelinux
Monday, February 27 2012, 7:44PM
“guys have a look here
Luke 6:37
and hopefully learn”
by rkch1ck
Monday, February 27 2012, 7:11PM
“An excellent Article. I can't wait for the day religion has no part in public life and is eradicated from schools. You wouldn't think that as a species we had evolved in to free thinkers!”
by E_D_Wivens
Monday, February 27 2012, 7:07PM
“Well you wouldn't find many people disagreeing with you there Johntoe, but remember how all this started; by Mike Wolfe trying to make out that Anglican prayers in council meetings were "somehow" the same as wannabe murderous Islamic fanatics, because "all" religions are ultimately the same - but it's patently a ridiculous proposal to suggest that a long-established and harmless tradition of formal CofE worship is in any way, shape or form equivalent to blowing people up in buses or tube trains or pubs. And this is the issue that I've had all along with this discussion - lack of perspective. Nobody's human rights are endangered by local councillors saying a few prayers, and it's a cheap trick to suggest that they are, and a dirtier trick to try to tie it with fanatical would-be terrorists. Now there are plenty of hard-core fundamentalist Christians in the world especially across the water who'd make your hair stand on end with some of their beliefs, these are people who if they ever got their finger on the button would usher in Armageddon and say alleluia praise be while they were doing it. Total fruitloops, very dangerous people. But that's not the CofE. One thing is not another thing.
I'm not altogether sure what Mike was trying to do, whether he was playing devil's advocate, genuinely trying to get discussion going or actually testing the water for a push to get rid of prayers at Stoke council meetings a la Clive Bone. The latter would certainly raise his left-wing credentials, if that's not too cynical a view (but he is a politician and it's a very low profession.)”
by Johntoe
Monday, February 27 2012, 5:45PM
“@ E_D_Wivens
I wasn't referring to you in particular mate, But to religious fundamentalists of all faiths, and that includes Huey Dooey and Louey in the report above,
They and their ilk believe that they are my moral and spiritual superiors, and it matters not that I am a decent chap, who has a good sense of right and wrong etc, Nope, I am a filthy unbeliever and therefore deserve to die, and when I do, I will burn in hell for eternity,
This is NOT a 'dig' at Islam, as one can find plenty of Christians who also believe that their God has given them permission to end the lives of those who offend him, or indeed, don't worship him in the 'proper' way, (Catholics & protestants, etc)
Yeah, no doubt religion has been good for humanity in many ways, but sadly the hatred death and misery it has caused over the centuries, right up to the present day, Far out weighs the good, in my opinion,
I think we would be better off without it,”
by Englishsense
Monday, February 27 2012, 4:30PM
“"I AM glad that our local trio of would-be terrorists will remain behind bars for a serious period" - The only two punishments for this degree of crime (planned to be inflicted on OUR OWN COUNTRY FOR GODSAKE) is life imprisonment or death penalty.
They have planned to kill X amount of people, innocent people I may add - so what right do they have to life? eye for an eye... shouldnt be in england and shouldnt have ever got to this stage. Out.”
by hawort
Monday, February 27 2012, 3:24PM
“Well I think religion is used and has been used for centuries to counternance wars, I also think our open borders invite terrorists to live side by side with us. you do not know who lives next door these days. Anyway I think anyone commiting any type of attack should be charged with Treason end of
All this HUMAN RIGHTS ****, is being used for the benefit of the criminals BUT its against my human rights to have to put up with these people why do we have to pay for there incarceration when they want to kill us cant we just shoot them and be done with it, Oh yeah we cant do that because we will breach there uman rights I thought if you became a terrorist and commited crimes against the state all your rights went out the window with them.
As for religion everyone has a right to believe in green men from mars, evolution or even thia bloke callled god but nobody ever proved the books told the real story. Anyhow its a good book but he died in the end. the quran is a good book it does not condone this type of act. therefore how can they say in the name of Alah because Alah /god or the green men from MARS. did not sanction there actions So they themselves chose to do these acts nothing to do with religion.
its all boils down to one fact England is a cushy number because they allow people like this liberty to walk the streets. They allow EU to bully them, They panic at the thought of dealing with anything face up.”
by E_D_Wivens
Monday, February 27 2012, 8:42AM
“"...your blind faith helps you get through life..... I just don't like those who follow ANY religion who think that their faith makes them my moral superior"
This is where you err, Johntoe, and grievously. You were doing well until you started making these assumptions. "Blind" faith? What exactly do you mean by that? If you mean unquestioning slavish devotion, you are very much mistaken my friend. As for your assertion regarding "moral superiority" - who has questioned your morals? Not me, nor anyone else here as far as I know. I'm afraid those comments say a lot more about your own prejudices and preconceptions than they do about anyone else's.
speccy - I thought that might be were you were heading; I was just waiting for your reply so I could be sure :) You do often find that many of the people who shriek the loudest for either camp know the least about it, and take everything quite literally as you say "on faith" without ever bothering to go and find out for themselves.
thetruth - couldn't have put it better myself sir and indeed was going to, but bedtime called. Interestingly I had a real-life experience of exactly that scenario - an American colleague of mine had come over to stay for a few weeks so on a spare day Mrs Wivens and I took him down to London for a day out, and in the afternoon we wendled our way to the Natural History museum. I wondered why he was looking at the dinosaur skeletons with bemusement and so asked what was the matter? To my astonishment he answered that he thought it was incredible that so many people had been fooled by these skeletons and that God had put the dinosaur bones and the rest of the fossil record in the ground as a test (of faith.) I laughed and asked if he was winding me up but he said in all sincerity that was what he genuinely held to be the truth, because the Bible said so. I had only ever considered this as an exercise in argument, never expecting for one moment that anyone might actually really believe it! But apparently it's quite popular across the big water, especially when you get out of the big coastal cities and into the small towns and backwoods. Americans; what can you do?”