Martin Smith: It's time to have a go against the likes of United
I HAVE a confession to make. I didn't go to Old Trafford the other night. I was going to go, up until very late in the day, but in the end I just couldn't face it.
After all, there's the Valencia trip coming up – and hopefully another tie after that against PSV Eindhoven – as well as a long-distance trek to Crawley Town in the FA Cup.
On top of all that, of course, season-ticket renewals are on the horizon.
Set against this was the sinking feeling of what we were likely to get from the game at Old Trafford – which sadly turned out as most of us suspected it would.
It's not that I won't go to games I think we're going to lose, but I am losing my enthusiasm for matches where I don't think we'll even try to win.
So instead of cheering on the lads in Manchester, I went to the pub.
It's my belief that we approach games against the "Big Six" with too much apprehension.
Fear is debilitating and prevents you from expressing yourself.
We seem to go into games at Old Trafford, the Etihad, Stamford Bridge et al worrying far too much about what the home team might do to us, rather than what problems we could pose them.
On paper, at least, the line-up at Old Trafford didn't look too bad, but appearances can be deceptive.
We may have had three strikers on the pitch, but one of them was playing deep on the left wing while another was effectively a midfielder, which left Peter Crouch isolated on his own up front.
In fact, our wingers were playing so deep that they were the ones who gave away the penalties which decided the game.
I'm no coach, but I have a pair of eyes. I also know all about statistics, so I was pretty sure it wasn't going to work.
We predictably sat too deep, gave away too much possession and created too few chances ourselves.
If you give a team like United 71 per cent of the possession on their own ground, they're going to do something with it. The sad fact is they didn't really need to break sweat.
Even though both Blackburn and Newcastle have taken points away from Old Trafford this season, I realise Sir Alex Ferguson's team remain a daunting prospect on their own turf.
They also put eight past Arsenal and hit four against Chelsea this season.
My complaint is we never seemed to give ourselves a fighting chance, and when I see that we're two goals down with Kenwyne Jones still holding a deep midfield role, I know we're not going to be getting anything for our efforts.
There's a school of thought that you can't go to grounds such as Old Trafford and expect to play football without being massacred.
With that in mind, I decided to look up our away record against the "Big Six" – Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Man City, Man Utd and Spurs – since we were promoted to the Premier League.
Of the 22 games we have played at their grounds over the past four seasons, we have won one, drawn two and lost 19.
In doing so, we have scored eight goals – four of them at White Hart Lane – and conceded 57.
To make a reasonable comparison, I also looked at Wigan's away record against the same teams over the same four-year period.
I chose Wigan because they are a club who tend to play a very open game, home or away.
They too, have a record of one win and two draws for a total of five points, while their goal difference is – wait for it – scored eight and conceded 58, almost no difference at all.
So why don't we play our own game and not worry too much about tactical tinkering?
After all, the stats tend to suggest it doesn't seem to be doing us any good.
We have good players and a good manager ... and we are capable of giving a better account of ourselves than we often do in these games.
But I see that as being positive, rather than negative.
I'd rather see us throw caution to the wind every now and then – which means when you've got a throw close to the Liverpool penalty area with a few seconds remaining, and Rory Delap is on the pitch, that you go for the glory, not hurl the ball towards the corner flag.
Games against the "Big Six" won't decide our Premier League destiny.
It's the games against our peers that are crucial and, in that respect, we all know this Saturday's visit of Sunderland is far more important than the game at Old Trafford.
All the more reason, of course, for "having a go" against the likes of United. What do we have to lose?
In the meantime, here's to a return to winning ways against Sunderland.









19 Comments
View all
by DJ_Stoke
Saturday, February 04 2012, 4:35AM
“Deadly his red card against Ronaldo says it all really... If he get's skinned he will tackle from behind or do whatever it takes really, proper Stoke really!!.... Saying that, we really do need proper fullbacks, but let's not get ahead of ourselves I guess, step at a time.
Ref's seem to give him a break so maybe we should too ?”
by deadlyscfc
Friday, February 03 2012, 11:44PM
“Derbys winger ran Wilko ragged last week.He dies for his shirt,but does not think,and often gives away needless fouls in important areas.Although the balance should be better with him in the side,it some how does not seem to work.”
by soccerfoot11
Friday, February 03 2012, 8:06PM
“flint, if if if . I saw 2 penalties that were called by the referee, neither one of them by Wilkinson!
IF Pulis played positively, IF we had someone who could marshall midfield, IF we scored more goals, IF we could hold possession for more than 3 passes at a time !”
by JTFLINT2009
Friday, February 03 2012, 12:26PM
“I've got to be fair to the other players sadly sf in saying that Wilko could also have forced the ref into giving a third penalty. Doesn't matter how well he'd played, if that pen had been given, his performance wouldn't have mattered as much. Still want him in the line-up v Sunderland but not sure if he'll make it...”
by soccerfoot11
Friday, February 03 2012, 11:37AM
“dj, im all for being optimistic but we didnt play well at all, and if it werent for some timely defending from Wilkinson and some bad shooting from Man U, it could have been 5- 0 !!”
by Jayenne
Friday, February 03 2012, 9:21AM
“With Walters down the left? A player that doesnt really defend the wings well and can't cross to track back to help a right footed left back vs the man United in form Winger Valencia. At least stick Delap there, or even stick Pennant there and play Jerome/Shotton downthe right (Doesnt Pulis remember how well Shotton payed against Spurs in right Mid?). Jones in the hole? are you serious? Ive given that lad patience but Jeez how lazy can a player be? He has gone to shot.
We may not have a strong squad and we may need to buy but Pulis doesnt seem to want to play the best team with the personnel he already has at his dosposal.”
by djdaz1210
Friday, February 03 2012, 3:46AM
“My opinion on tony pulis. Genuine guy who wears his heart on his sleeve. He cares about stoke city. But, he does need to make stoke play different. He totally respects the chairman and his family, he just wants stoke to stay in the premier league for them, hence, his style of play. I worry that if they carry on playing negatively, players might not want to come and play for the club. Alot of stoke players are getting older. People around the country do still see stoke as a long ball, defensive team. Free flowing total football would be great, but different players are needed. Im sorry to say this but i can see stoke getting relegated in the next two years. Sorry. By the way, i support stockport county, do feel for me. A positive though, stoke sell out every week, good thing, county also get a good gate still. prediction sat. Stoke 0 sunderland 0”
by DJ_Stoke
Friday, February 03 2012, 1:57AM
“I mean he did set us up to play an attacking game, with a really good squad. Although TP looked really upset throughout the match as the players kept sitting SO deep. The only issue I had with the team was that Jones started, I thought that was odd too start him over Jerome.
I think we played well at times actually, and we may have even nicked a point with a clean sheet had we not given away two sloppy penalties.”
by JTFLINT2009
Friday, February 03 2012, 1:00AM
“This is the frustrating thing about supporting a football club that we are forced to be so distant from these types of decisions. i.e. how we can't question TPs tactics in games like these. How hard is it to have a 'Ask the Manager' session once a season, so that we - the supporters - have a chance to ask the manager questions such as these? Surely not that hard!”
by britbrick
Thursday, February 02 2012, 11:24PM
“I went to the game at Old Trafford, and I couldnt agree more with your views, Martin. I also went to Arsenal, Liverpool, and Man City and saw us do precisely the same thing - give them too much respect. If the likes of Swansea and Norwich can 'give it a go', why can't we? It really is quite depressing....”