'Let's not go back to winter accident unit misery'
TWO schemes designed to help end last winter's misery at North Staffordshire's accident unit are under threat in a funding row.
Both initiatives have helped cut the marathon queues of frail and elderly patients on trolleys, which blighted the University Hospital. But the NHS bodies which pay for them say they are costing too much.
Now community leaders fear the schemes may be cut – and the nightmare scenes which brought direct action from the Government could return this winter.
The Sentinel has learned the projects are being reviewed because the hospital is spending £20 million more than North Staffordshire's two primary care trusts agreed to give it to run its services this year.
The figure represents five per cent of the UHNS's budget. Hospital and PCT chief executives will meet on Friday to try to settle the dispute, with two directors from the West Midlands Strategic Health Authority acting as mediators.
One of the schemes was the opening in April of the new Ward 21. Its 22 beds are used either for emergency patients referred directly from GPs or to rescue elderly patients held up in the casualty department.
The other scheme was the creation of a separate primary care urgent care unit (PCUCU) within A&E staffed by GPs and nurse practitioners. Opened two years ago and extended more recently, its aim was to prevent people from needing to be admitted to a scarce hospital bed.
Since the schemes were established, delays have been slashed and 98 per cent of all patients are treated within four hours of arrival at the hospital. This is an official Government target.
But each patient sent to Ward 21 costs the PCTs £800 and their officials say the PCUCU – which sees 8,000 patients a year – is expensive yet "not delivering the level of service we require".
North Staffordshire PCT finance director Mark Day confirmed that £20 million was in dispute. He said: "The four-hour wait is currently being met, but at enormous cost."
Trust chief executive Tony Bruce, pictured, added: "Even though the target is being hit, it is still not spectacular for people to wait four hours. The A&E performance is better than it was, but not much better."
He said the future of the PCUCU was already under review and although there were no plans to "part company" with Ward 21 at present, its future would be part of the dispute resolution on Friday.
Hospital officials say the higher spending has been needed to treat the increasing number of patients who are referred.
And last night, health watchdogs in Stoke-on-Trent voiced fears of a repeat of last winter's A&E chaos if Ward 21 and the PCUCU were scrapped. Alby Walker, chairman of the city council health scrutiny committee, said: "We had been assured they both took pressure off A&E.
"Last winter almost everyone I spoke to had a horror story about the place. It is deeply worrying if we go back to that."
North Staffordshire GP leader Dr Paul Golik said: "There are now so many portals of entry for emergencies at the hospital each with their own criteria that it is a joke.
"We have to speak to three people for each patient referral so GPs will just refer straight to A&E and that defeats the object."











5 Comments
by sharon, stoke
Thursday, November 26 2009, 2:50PM
“again its money over people, no wonder people are losing their lives”
by Pam, Stoke
Tuesday, November 24 2009, 9:46AM
“My daugther was admitted with a severe kidney infection last year, we had a nightmare ordeal in the accident unit, but, thankfully she was transfered to the PCUCU and was admitted to a ward for 5 days for treatment of her infection. The staff on the PCUCU were fantastic and I am very gratefuly to them!!”
by Ranting, Talke
Monday, November 23 2009, 3:52PM
“Once again the grey, nameless, shameless, faces make the voices heard for the sake of a few quid.
So £20million pounds, or 5% of the annual spend. What an absolute bargain for the the main route into hospital, That's GP referrals, Accidents, critical patients, and walking wounded, 24 hours a day 365 days a year.
I'd imagine that they are same people who had the vision to build a new hospital complex with 250 less beds than the old one it replaces.
My advice is that they spend some time in the neurology department , they need to have their brains looked at, they obviously have problem perceiving the real world, and what is, and isn't important to people.”
by Lewis, Hanley
Monday, November 23 2009, 3:36PM
“A lot of the queuing and long waiting times could be avoided if people who didnt actually need A&E care used other sources of help such as walk in centres and their GP. Time to get tough and clamp down on people unnecessarily visiting A&E when they dont need it.”
by Andi, Stoke
Monday, November 23 2009, 2:45PM
“Money can always be found for wars , banks , the EU & immigration . Reasons can always be found to tax us more, but legitimate reasons for additional funding to provide essential services go unheard . But don't worry Premier Brown and his cronies will be looked after at our expense.”