Protesters vow to fight on after academy school site chosen

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, August 07, 2010
Profile image for This is Staffordshire

This is Staffordshire

CAMPAIGNERS have vowed to continue fighting plans for a controversial academy after a community centre was chosen as its location.

The Willfield Community Education Centre in Bentilee was yesterday selected as the site for the Discovery Academy by Stoke-on-Trent City Council's Building Schools for the Future (BSF) board.

Longton's Edensor Technology College and Mitchell Business and Enterprise College, Bucknall, are to merge to form the new school, which is expected to open in 2013.

Around 1,600 pupils attend these two schools.

But Mitchell's chairman of governors Pat Smith, pictured, said the school intended to fight the decision by organising a petition to keep the school on the same site.

She said: "The issue is still that there should not be two schools. We have suggested having the Discovery Academy in Longton and leaving us to become a co-operative school.

"It is a merger that we don't feel we need. Mergers de-stabilise employees as they all go for the same job and the best staff leave.

"Students would also have much further to travel to school at the new location."

Margaret Lowe, chairman of the Community School Action Group, which wants to see Mitchell's current site used for the development, is also against the Willfield choice.

She said: "We will be heavily opposing the application at the planning stage. We still think that they are bringing the wrong schools together.

"They are in two different areas, and are two perfectly good schools which are making good progress. Edensor pupils won't want to come down to Bentilee because of the reputation of the area, much of which is unfounded. Mitchell pupils don't want to go over there because of the travel that is involved."

Tom Simpson, manager of Bentilee Volunteers, said the organisation used the Willfield Centre regularly for projects and luncheon clubs.

He said: "We won't be taking this lying down. Closure of the centre would affect us greatly. Where else is there nearby? We have Bentilee Neighbourhood Centre, but that is already over-subscribed."

The Bentilee site came out as the top choice for the Discovery Academy in a £150,000 study commissioned by the city council.

A total of 12 sites were looked at as a potential location for the academy, with the top three emerging as Mossfield Industrial Estate, Adderley Green and Willfield. The study showed it would cost £28.8 million to develop the Mossfield site, £28.3 million to develop the Adderley Green site and £25.9 million for Willfield.

BSF programme director Tracey Penrose-Gould said: "The brief given to the advisers was to find a site which was equidistant to suit students at both sites. We asked them to look at suitability such as whether it was big enough, accessibility and minimal planning risk.

"The results were that there was no perfect site, but this site met the criteria best."

Councillor Debra Gratton, cabinet member for children and young people's services, said it had not yet been decided whether the community centre would be demolished.

She said: "This is something that will be addressed in the planning application.

"We would be encouraging all of our schools to have community use. There are alternative facilities at the Bentilee Centre nearby."

A planning application is due in October, when residents will be able to comment.

Like this story? Share it with friends

6
Tweet this article
Report

6 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Nicky, pitsnpots.co.uk

    Wednesday, August 11 2010, 12:43AM

    “p.s. for accuracy, CSAG had a change of chair at AGM 28th July.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Nicky, pitsnpots.co.uk

    Wednesday, August 11 2010, 12:32AM

    “Two of Mervin Smith's election claims: a school on Mitchell, save Willfield. One trashed, probably taking the other with it. Labour and their coalition control the council, they have no excuse for going back on promises.

    "Around 1,600 pupils attend these two schools." Planned academy acommodates 1,200. They still can't do their arithmetic can they?

    £150,000 wasted on a study starting from a flawed remit to merge the wrong schools. More to be wasted on road changes needed to allow travel from Longton to Willfield. Pedestrian crossing would be needed on Park Hall Road, pavements widened on Dividy Road and I don't know what's to be done with that mess called the Mayflower Park apartments. Road changes are NOT allowed out of BSF funds - so how will this be paid for? We're supposedly being cut so how can we squander this money we don't have?

    Debra Gratton "said it had not yet been decided whether the community centre would be demolished" - typical tactic. "There are alternative facilities at the Bentilee Centre nearby." What - swimming pool, gym (recently refurbished at that)? Not making sense.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by paul, bentilee

    Monday, August 09 2010, 10:11PM

    “"Councillor Debra Gratton, cabinet member for children and young people's services, said it had not yet been decided whether the community centre would be demolished." If it's to be changed back into a school, academy or any other fancy name, why would it need to be demolished and not just refurbished? Somebody, somewhere is always going to be making a fast buck.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Paul, Trentham

    Monday, August 09 2010, 1:21PM

    “This merger comes under the acronym BSF, Building Schools Far from where the children live.
    What can you say about the wisdom of a Local Education Authority, which closes Willfield High in 1989 and then decides to resurrect it again 21 years later?
    The same LEA, which built a state of the art VI Form College in Fenton in 1970, only to demolish it 40 years later.
    The City Council has been trying to divest itself of Willfield CEC for the last ten years.
    This was always going to be their outcome for Willfield.
    Will the City Council be repaying the millions of pounds of Tax Payer monies which were pumped into Willfield CEC fitness and conference centres by the LSC?”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Chris, Newstead

    Monday, August 09 2010, 12:08AM

    “Well said KP.

    To be honest i have always thought this would be the chosen location for the academy all the other suggestions were put in place just to gain longterm support for willfield.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by kp, Trentham

    Saturday, August 07 2010, 4:18PM

    “I can't pretend to be suprised by this announcement. The site is a former high school and must be more suitable than some of the others that have been suggested over the past few years.
    Whilst I believe that a merger between Edensor and Mitchel is a ridiculous proposal because the two schools are far too far apart geographically. The council has found itself in its current position because of the abject failure of SERCO and former officers to consult properly and most importantly take notice of the feedback received at the very start of the whole BSF process.
    It is imperative that if this site is finally chosen that the current community facilities ( gym, swimming pool, and meeting facilities) are not only preserved but improved and run on a "not for profit" basis by the academy sponsor. Anything less would be a betrayal of the Bentilee community.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters