Asylum seekers in line for payout after delay

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, January 23, 2010
Profile image for This is Staffordshire

This is Staffordshire

A FAMILY of asylum seekers are in line to receive tens of thousands of pounds in damages after they were unlawfully detained for three weeks.

A High Court judge yesterday ruled that Fred Nukagem, and his wife and children, were held for too long prior to a planned deportation to Cameroon due to the "procedural ineptitude" of immigration authorities.

Negotiations are now underway over how much should be paid to Mr Nukagem.

And the legal team for the 38-year-old, from Middleport, is also hoping to reach an agreement over a compensation settlement for his wife and three children.

Solicitor Hani Zubeidi, of London-based Fadiga and Co, said: "We are looking at tens of thousands of pounds because, quite frankly, this is a shocking case."

Mr Nukagem, who says he and his family will be killed for political reasons if they return to Cameroon, claimed asylum after initially arriving in the country in 2003 as a student and later working illegally.

But his application was turned down and immigration officers raided his home.

He and wife Sandra Mbelle Yanga, as well as three-year-old twins Grace and Josepha, and Julie Sandra, aged one, were taken to Yarl's Wood Immigration Removal Centre on November 5, 2008.

They were due to be deported five days later, which would give authorities the chance to administer one to two days of a pre-dosage of anti-malarial drugs to the children.

But it later emerged the UK Border Agency had been given the wrong information about the drug, as Mefloquine requires three weeks of pre-dosage.

The family were released on bail on November 26.

During a High Court hearing in December, Mr Nukagem's lawyers argued the period of detention was unlawful as the family had been locked up on a misunderstanding.

They said, even with the right information, the family would have been detained for too long.

The lawyers also said there was also no reasonable basis to think they would flee as the family had complied with conditions imposed as part of their asylum application.

Yesterday, Judge David Elvin told the court: "While this form of delay and procedural ineptitude is all too frequent in this area of the law, and may be understandable up to a point – although not necessarily excusable – it is a particular cause for concern and criticism in circumstances which involve the detention of young children.

"Indeed, the handling of this case as a whole, both prior to and following the bringing of judicial review, fails in several respects to meet the requirements of both the public interest in an efficient immigration system and the protection of individual rights."

A judicial review over the family's right to remain in the UK is ongoing.

Negotiations over damages should be complete within 56 days.

Mr Nukagem, of Port Street, said: "We cannot go back to Cameroon. If we do we will be murdered because of my links to political groups.

"I'm quite prepared to contribute to society. I have paid taxes and everything in the past, and I've never been in trouble with the police. I just want a better future for my family."

Matthew Coats, head of immigration for the UK Border Agency said: "We are disappointed with the court's judgment.

"These people had no legal right to be in this country and our aim was to remove them as quickly as possible.

"We will learn lessons from this case.

"We are committed to providing protection to those genuinely in need of it."

43
Tweet this article
Report

43 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Victoria, Sydney

    Monday, January 25 2010, 5:25AM

    “''I think all the non British should be sent back to there own country and dealt with there its nothing to do with England''

    Okay - let's do that shall we and watch the NHS collapse, the British service industry collapse, the building trade collapse....

    Many immigrants come to the UK to work and they pay TAXES which contribute to the upkeep of the state.

    I myself am in Australia doing the exact same thing.

    I am an immigrant here. As are you, in Portugal. Should you be sent home? After all you're English - living in Portugal?

    Try please, Julie (and I know this may be difficult for you) to consider for a moment the BENEFITS that immigration brings to a country. And try to refrain from making ill informed sweeping statements about immigration before you've actually sat down and thought it through.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by mandy, newcastle

    Sunday, January 24 2010, 11:15PM

    “Julie, I'm so glad you left. We really don't need ignorant idiots like you. Please stay in Portugal as I'm much happier knowing you are there and I am here.

    There is a God after all.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Julie, Portugal/ Newchapel

    Sunday, January 24 2010, 9:15PM

    “This is why i moved all my family to PORTUGAL,how can it be called Great Britain or even England when this happens,i worked all my life in the UK paying all my taxes and what for so people like this can sponge off my taxes and the goverment,well the so called goverment.Im not racist at all well i wasnt its the goverment that have made me this way,i HATE england im ashamed to call it my birth place. To know that when we work all the hours god sends and feel like we are being treated as an outsider while people sit on there back sides all day and earn more money than i do and they are not even born and bred in England.THE GOVERMENT NEED TO LOOK AFTER ITS OWN british people who put something into the system before anyone else.I think all the non British should be sent back to there own country and dealt with there its nothing to do with England,I mean you watch Crime watch nowadays and there is not 1 white man on there,like i went back to Stoke before xmas god knows why because hardly anyone spoke English at all.I dont mind the people white or black as long as they are born and bred English.i think the rest of them are just scroungers,and they always use the excuse dont send me back i will be killed they need to think up a new lie because this one is wearing thin,as i said im ashamed to be British,im glad i got my son out of there when i did im not having my son bought up with gun and knife crime and most of all drugs which these people do all the time.
    The worst thing we did when we were kids was knock and run now you are scared to walk the streets because what England has turned into and its only since they let anyone into our Country.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by magneto, shelton

    Sunday, January 24 2010, 9:14PM

    “I do hope that this affair doesn't sour relations between our 2 countries. I'm quite partial to coconut cameroons and a trade embargo is likely to affect supply.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Richard, Burslem

    Sunday, January 24 2010, 11:34AM

    “There's always a "Human Rights Lawyer" waiting just around the corner, just ask Cherie Blair, the human rights act needs to be scrapped and a referendum called for any re-introduction and its future make up. We also need a "British Constitution" to be introduced urgently, so that immigrants who are "fortunate enough" to be considered to live here, then know what is expected of them, and not just come here and do what you please. so either adhere to our constitution or clear off.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters