Alton Towers noise battle case on hold

Trusted article source icon
Friday, September 12, 2008
Profile image for This is Staffordshire

This is Staffordshire

A COUPLE has withdrawn a private prosecution against Alton Towers over claims the park is too noisy.

Stephen and Suzanne Roper, who live in Farley next to the resort, were scheduled to meet with theme park officials at North Staffordshire Magistrates' Court in Newcastle on Monday.

They claimed Alton Towers exceeded limits set out in a noise abatement order, enforced in October 2005 after the couple won a private prosecution against them.

But their solicitor, Richard Buxton, said today: "Stephen and Suzanne Roper confirm that their prosecution against Alton Towers for breach of the abatement order has been withdrawn.

"The reason for this is that Alton Towers has explained that the subsidiary company responsible for operating the park has changed as a result of a corporate reorganisation so it is no longer right to prosecute the company against whom the abatement order was made (Tussauds Theme Parks Limited)."

Mr Roper said: "We were only told this by Alton Towers a few weeks ago after we had done a lot of work on the case.

"As far as we and others are concerned the nuisance is as bad as ever. The case is not over and we are considering how to ensure that this theme park operates as the planners originally intended it should – without "aural intrusion" on the neighbourhood and without, as the courts have twice decided it was, creating a legal nuisance."

Divisional director at Alton Towers, Russell Barnes said: "Of course We are pleased that Mr and Mrs Roper have agreed to withdraw their complaint. We have always sought to be a responsible and co-operative neighbour.

"We have made substantial changes to reduce our controllable noise sources, but there will always remain elements that we can not change, such as screaming; we are after all a theme park resort which encourages people of all ages to enjoy themselves. We always believed that this latest claim had no prospect of succeeding. It has been a very long, and no doubt very expensive, process for Mr and Mrs Roper with little or no benefit to anyone other than lawyers over the years."

The Ropers's anger has been focused on noise from the public address system, rides, firework displays and screaming thrill-seekers.

Theme park visitor Christopher McDonnell, a 28-year-old engineer, said: "It's not even that noisy inside the park. And even in the queues the noise doesn't seem to be over the legal limit. I can't see how it can be too much of a disturbance at a house outside of the grounds."

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by mike, derbyshire

    Wednesday, October 29 2008, 12:51PM

    “Alton towers theme park is in a crud location, there local infrastructure is not suitable, anyone who has driven there knows that. while the theme park provides both employment and entertainment which is to be commended, they choose to have a theme park at a unsuitable location, so they should do EVERYTHING possible to limit there impact on local residents.
    The Ropers are decent people who believe in fighting for what they believe is right. The character assassination of them on this web site is totally unjust.
    as someone who worked in Farley for a while there was definitely a lot of noise created by the theme park, and i don't think expecting the Park to do everything possible to reduce it is unreasonable, especially as the Ropers have lived in there home at Farley before Alton towers became a theme park. Its very telling that the people verbally attacking the Ropers all seem to live away from the immediate impact of the theme park, I wonder how they would react if it was at the bottom of there garden? and no i am not related or close friends with Mr & Mrs Roper, they are decent people who I had the pleasure of knowing for a while.
    Mike.R”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Craig Chapman, Tamworth (near dryaton manor!)

    Thursday, September 25 2008, 3:29AM

    “Now this stupid case has been put to rest maybe Alton Towers can get back to doing there excellent firework displays again! :)”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by NEILingdown, newcastle

    Friday, September 12 2008, 3:18PM

    “Have the Roper's seen the light , or run out of money?.Warren,love your new gadget,”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by john., shelton

    Friday, September 12 2008, 1:53PM

    “Chris mcdonald hit the nail on the head when he said it not that noisy inside the park,he,s right i went with my family two months ago and went on a few of the big rides but left the kid and the wife to it while i had a walk round the lovely grounds
    and he,s right its quite peace full
    away from the main rides and let,s face it the park has been open to the public since the late 1800s so there has all been some amount of noise and traffic.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Donna Thomson, Newstead

    Friday, September 12 2008, 1:11PM

    “These comments make me giggle!! Hehe!! moaning about fireworks!!! They should live round here they start in october and finish mid january!!. The Ropers must of been young once.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article