£180k LOST IN BRITANNIA SALE

Trusted article source icon
Friday, January 29, 2010
Profile image for This is Staffordshire

This is Staffordshire

DETAILS of Stoke City's £4.5 million purchase of the Britannia Stadium were kept from city councillors as the authority missed out on £180,000 in interest payments, The Sentinel can reveal.

A leaked copy of Stoke-on-Trent City Council's internal audit report into the stadium sale reveals that the £4.5 million price was agreed by councillors in June 2007.

But the then council manager Steve Robinson and Elected Mayor Mark Meredith never told councillors the cash would be paid in interest-free instalments.

It meant the council received a dividend payment of £480,000, £1.52 million and then two payments of £1.25 million over two years to December 2009 – leaving the council missing out on £180,000 in interest payments if they had received the £4.5 million upfront and invested it in a bank account.

The report has cleared officers and councillors of any financial wrong-doing. But the District Auditor is expected to criticise a system which allowed the council manager and elected mayor to make major decisions and saw councillors kept in the dark.

The council report states: "It would seem to have been good practice, although not necessary, to report back to full council regarding the detail of the final payment terms."

The city council invested £3.14 million in the stadium development in 1996 before selling its stake for £4.5 million on December 21, 2007. Stoke City chairman Peter Coates agreed to pay £4.5 million in staged payments for the stadium during a meeting with Mr Robinson on May 16, 2007.

The overall payment was then approved at a meeting of the full council in June 2007 – although councillors never knew about the staged payments because the details had not been finalised.

Mr Robinson said: "The transaction was carried out legally and totally within the bounds of the council's constitution and the corporate governance in place."

Mr Meredith, who also knew about the staged payments, said: "I think we got a good deal. If the payment had been made up front, we would have probably got a lot less."

Mr Robinson claims in the report that Councillor Roger Ibbs and the then Labour leader Mike Tappin also knew about the staged payments. But they have told investigators they only found out once the deal had been signed.

Mr Tappin said: "We were not told it was staged payments until after we signed the contract."

Details of the internal audit report were discussed by councillors at yesterday's full council meeting.

Councillor Paul Billington, pictured, who has previously called for answers over the deal, said: "This inquiry has caused all manner of upset."

The internal report will be discussed at a meeting next month. Mr Ibbs was unavailable for comment.

21
Tweet this article
Report

21 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by ray, stoke

    Saturday, January 30 2010, 1:22AM

    “"Once again an over hyped football club has benefited from a morally bankrupt council decision"

    The football club is run as a successful business and good for Stoke City that it is.

    The council of Stoke on Trent is not "morally Bankrupt" it is corrupt and inept.

    I am not a football fan but please, do not blame the football club because our city has been dragged to it's knees.

    S.C.F.C are doing the city proud.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by al, stoke

    Saturday, January 30 2010, 12:41AM

    “so when are central government going finally sort out this rubbish council and investigate all its questionable actions..”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Adam, Meir Park

    Friday, January 29 2010, 10:32PM

    “Yes, nasty Stoke, how dare their chairman have more brains and business acumen than that of everyone on the council combined?

    It's a travesty that the council closed down that illegal market that Port Vale used to run. How dare the council uphold the law like that, bad council.”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by mh, stoke on trent

    Friday, January 29 2010, 9:09PM

    “and people wonder why the council is bankrupt, in the red at the bank for over £45 million, officers not aware of teh details of deals, councillors not aware of teh same, other councillors aware but conveniently not telling any of their collegues..typical stoke on trent city council fubar realy isnt it.
    A nd they wonder why noone has got no respect for them ?”

  • Profile image for This is Staffordshire

    by Richard, Burslem

    Friday, January 29 2010, 8:39PM

    “How about Peter Coates for City Council Chief Exec, a shrewd guy, knows a good deal when he sees one. will we ever get anybody at the council with half a business brain ? then of course there's the "waste of space" councillors who are just in it for the pension. lucky if you can get em to answer the phone, as for an email reply , "No Chance"”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article